Opens in a new tab

StoryNaro

Accurate Enough to Be Dangerous

Chapter 2 of 5
Nothing Strenuous
Chapters

On Tuesday, I arrived at the café with three versions of myself in my phone and a fourth in my head.

The first was a woman who loved spontaneous weekends, live music, and trying anything once. The second had recently discovered that she enjoyed long walks, although the only long walk I could remember enjoying had ended at a bakery. The third was honest enough to be useful and polished enough to avoid making anyone ask follow-up questions.

Emlyn was already at our table with two coffees. I drew the crossword from my tote and spread it between us. He looked up as I sat down.

“Which version did you bring?”

“The one with the excellent lighting.” I put my phone beside his. “I’ve prepared copy.”

“I brought the truth.”

“Show-off.”

He had, in fact, brought no written draft. I’d expected that. Emlyn seemed to prefer discovering what he thought while saying it, which was a quality I admired in conversation and would have found inconvenient in a meeting agenda.

I turned my screen toward him. “Here. ‘I’m happiest when life takes an unexpected turn. Equally at home at a concert, on a country walk, or trying a new restaurant. Looking for someone curious, kind, and ready to make the most of every day.’”

He read it, then looked at me. “Do you go to concerts?”

“Sometimes.”

“Recently?”

“I went to one last year.”

“Did you enjoy it?”

“I enjoyed the first half.”

“And the walk?”

“I’ve done a walk.”

“Was it in the country?”

“It was near a country.”

His mouth twitched. “And the restaurant?”

“I like restaurants.”

“Then that part’s true.”

“Thank you. I was hoping for a little support.”

“I’m trying to work out what you’d want someone to know.” He rested his forearms on the table, giving my phone the same attention he’d given the ingredients on Monday. “What happens when life takes an unexpected turn?”

“I adapt.”

“You told me you leave dates when they start to feel like auditions.”

“I leave dates when I’m not enjoying them. That’s sensible.”

“Of course.” He didn’t smile at the line. That made me hear the joke as a door I’d closed. “But you put ‘ready to make the most of every day.’ Does that sound like you?”

“I can make the most of a day.”

“Monday, you were annoyed about missing lunch.”

“I was hungry.”

“You asked the owner what food was still possible, and when he offered us bread and vegetables, you talked him into letting us help. Then you made me explain why I thought mustard belonged on a sandwich.”

“Mustard does belong on a sandwich.”

“That’s a separate debate.”

I took a sip of coffee. It had cooled enough to taste like coffee rather than a warning. “You’re saying I should advertise my ability to negotiate for lunch?”

“I’m saying that’s what I saw you do.”

He tapped the screen, then pulled his hand back. “Would it be all right if I tried a version?”

“You’re the copywriter. I’m the difficult client.”

He dictated slowly, giving me room to object. “‘I’m good at making an afternoon out of whatever’s available. Recently persuaded a café owner to let a couple of strangers help make lunch. I like a good story, a good meal, and people who can disagree about mustard without making it a referendum on their character.’”

“‘Couple of strangers’ sounds like we were about to rob the place.”

“Then change it.”

I read the lines again. They were specific in a way that made me feel caught mid-action, without the flattering angle I usually supplied afterward. “Maybe ‘two hungry strangers.’”

“Better.”

“And the referendum line is too long.”

“It’s accurate.”

“It’s a dating profile, not a transcript of our entire afternoon.”

He raised his coffee. “You can take it out.”

I kept it. We shortened the sentence and changed “good story” to “stories worth telling twice.” We added a line about my favorite bookshop. The profile sounded more like me, though I wasn’t sure whether the stories were a promise or a warning.

“Now you,” I said. “I’ve been saving my best material.”

“That sounds ominous.”

“It is affectionate.”

I started with the obvious: his patience, his dry humor, the way he listened without reaching for the next thing to say. Then I erased most of it. Patience could sound saintly. Dry humor could mean he was rude. “Listens well” sounded like the sort of claim you put on a profile when you had no hobbies.

I watched him work through the crossword clue for a vegetable, pencil poised over the page. He didn’t fill in an answer until he’d checked the crossing letters. Even his guesses wanted company.

“Try this,” I said. “‘Curious about almost everything, including whether mustard improves a sandwich and what makes a crossword clue fair. Appreciates a good meal, a clear explanation, and a question that doesn’t have an obvious answer.’”

“Almost everything is a lot to promise.”

“I’ve seen you investigate sandwich fillings with the focus of a man preparing testimony.”

“I wanted to know what you thought belonged in one.”

“You asked me to rank the options.”

“Because you had a strong opinion.”

“I did.”

He took the phone from the table and read the text again. “Does that sound tedious?”

The question was quiet. He didn’t make a joke to soften it or look away from the words. I could have said, No, of course not, in the breezy tone I used when I wanted a subject to pass. Instead, I heard how often people called someone tedious when they meant that the person had stayed interested past the point where they themselves would have stopped.

“No,” I said. “It sounds like you notice things most people miss.”

He held my gaze a moment, then glanced down at the screen. “That’s a better line.”

“Use it, then.”

He added it, but changed “most people” to “I might,” which was both less grand and more inviting. The final version read: “Curious about almost everything, including what makes a crossword clue fair and whether mustard improves a sandwich. I notice details, ask questions, and like a conversation that wanders somewhere interesting.”

I approved it. He approved mine, including the mustard referendum. We each took our own phones and made the changes ourselves. He read his profile aloud before uploading it; I read mine. Neither of us tried to improve the other person’s wording after that.

“Ready?” I asked.

“I think so.”

“Good. We’re about to become irresistible.”

“Let’s aim for interesting.”

I pressed save. “That’s what irresistible people say.”

We worked on the crossword after, but the profiles had left us looking at each other with the odd attention of people who had just taken notes. I tried to settle into the old rhythm. He filled in a clue; I disputed it. He asked what evidence I had. I pointed to a letter, which turned out to be wrong. When he laughed, I could still feel the warmth of it after I’d found the right answer.

Before we left, we made a rule. If either of us got attention, we had to share the credit.

“Not the messages,” Emlyn said. “Those are private.”

“Obviously. Just the general news. We can’t hoard each other’s appeal.”

“Nor can we take responsibility for it.”

“I’ll take partial responsibility. I wrote excellent copy.”

“You did.”

The agreement was light enough to pass for a joke. I left the café pleased with the profile, pleased with the afternoon, and pleased that Emlyn had agreed I was good at something.

That evening, my phone began to make the arrangement look clever.

One message asked about the bookshop I’d mentioned in my profile. Another was from a man whose opening line included an actual question about what I liked to read. I answered both. A third invitation came from someone who suggested coffee and a walk, then followed it with an escape clause: we could stay for one drink if the weather or company failed us.

I laughed at that. It was considerate, funny, and specific enough to suggest he’d read what I’d written. I found myself composing a reply before I’d finished judging the photograph. By the time I put my phone down, I had a promising exchange underway and the pleasant little fizz of being wanted by someone who had made an effort.

Then I remembered the rule and wondered whether Emlyn had heard from anyone.

His message came later, brief and pleased: An invitation. She liked the crossword line. Apparently that’s a niche market.

I read it twice. The reply I sent—Excellent. Don’t waste your niche—was appropriately supportive. I even added a laughing face.

I was happy for him. I was also, to my surprise, annoyed at a woman I had never met for finding him interesting so quickly.

I set my phone facedown and went to bed thinking about my own invitations, which were genuine, flattering, and quite possibly good prospects. The inconvenience was that I had expected Emlyn’s success to feel more abstract. I’d written the words myself. I knew exactly what she had liked.

Comments 0

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a Comment

Log in to use bookmarks.